There's that silly argument again
Over at Espn's Page 2, there is a little debate between Kieran Darcy and Scoop Jackson on which freshman sensation is better, Ohio State's Greg Oden or Texas' Kevin Durant.
Darcy gives 10 reasons to pick Oden while Scoop sides with Durant. My severe dyslexia and short attention span kept me from reading the full article but one of Darcy's arguments did manage to poke my retina ever so gently.
Now, I don't want to make it seem like I can give better analysis. Ofcourse I can't. My analogy would be something like this. "Oden looks like he's 52. Draft Durant." But still, I hate it when people bring up the fact that a certain player doesn't have a ring and that some other player is better because he does have a ring.
A lot more than just individual talent comes in to play. Trent Dilfer. Dan Marino. That should make it as clear as possible. Either way, here's Darcy's take.
"Oden is poised to be a franchise center, someone you can build a team around. Franchise centers usually win championships. His name's already being mentioned in the company of Russell, Robinson, Olajuwon, and Shaq. Lot of rings on those fingers.
Durant is most often compared to Tracy McGrady and Kevin Garnett. Some people project him as a combination of the two. That's pretty darn good – but I don't see any rings on their fingers."
David Robinson. Got his two titles only after the Spurs drafted Tim Duncan 1st overall. Had a team in '99 with Duncan, Sean Elliot, Avery Johnson and Mario Ellie. The 2003 squad included Duncan, Manu Ginobili, Tony Parker and Bruce Bowen.
Hakeem Olajuwon. Won titles in Houston with a great team that included Clyde Drexler, Robert Horry, Sam Cassell, Vernon Maxwell and Mario Ellie. Let's not forget that Rudy T. was also at the helm.
Shaq. Came close with Penny, Nick Anderson Dennis Scott and Horace Grant in Orlando. Eventually won with Kobe, Derek Fisher, Robert Horry, Rick Fox etc. in L.A. Also won with Dwayne Wade, Antoine Walker, Gary Payton, Udonis Haslem and some other decent veteran players in Miami. In L.A. Shaq had Phil Jackson as his coach. In Miami he won with Pat Riley. You can't ask for more than that.
On the flip side...
McGrady. Had Vince Carter and not much more in Toronto. Had an injured Grant Hill in Orlando and now has his best chance at a title in Houston, but that's because he has Yao Ming, Shane Battier, Bonzi Wells and Juwan Howard. Still not the best of teams, but definitely better than where he was.
Garnett. No real argument needed here. President Bush gets more support than this guy and that's a fact. That KG hasn't hanged himself yet is a pretty amazing feat.
The point is that both guys should be great and that both could lead their respective teams to titles, but not without good teammates and not without a coach that won't screw it up.
Either way, stay tuned for my Miami Dolphins season review, in which I will embarrass myself with analogy in which I fail to even use basic pre-school math correctly.





