My favorite football writer next to Paul Zimmerman is Don Banks from SI. As bad as Peter King is, Dr. Z and Don Banks more than make up for it.
Well, Banks dropped his mid-season awards today and while I agree with most of what he says, I find his pick for worst coaching hire a bit harsh.
• Best coaching hire -- Wade Phillips, Dallas -- He was lampooned as a three-time loser when Jerry Jones tabbed him to replace Bill Parcells, but who's laughing now? The Cowboys are 7-1 for the first time since 1995, when a jokester named Barry Switzer won the franchise's most recent Super Bowl title, and they have arrived at midseason as the odds-on favorite to represent the NFC in Arizona in February.
• Runner up: Mike Tomlin, Pittsburgh.
• Worst coaching hire -- Cam Cameron, Miami -- The Dolphins are a train wreck, and it's certainly not all Cameron's fault. But at 0-8, you can't claim his presence has been a difference maker.
Here's the thing. Mike Tomlin is doing a great job with the Steelers and they are obviously the closest thing to Indy and New England in the AFC. Phillips is also doing a good job with the Cowboys who are still my NFC Super Bowl pick but both these men took over very good rosters.
Tomlin basically took over the same team that won the Super Bowl two years ago and they may be even better right now with the additions of Santonio Holmes, James Harrison and a more mature Ben Roethlisberger.
Phillips also took over a loaded roster and while he is a "defensive" coach, it's been the offense that has been good while the defense itself has been up and down. I may be wrong here but I think that Jason Garrett has been more important to Dallas this season than Wade Phillips.
As for Cameron being the worst hire. I understand that at 0-8 and with questionable calls like the Joey Porter signing, the Trent Green era and the Ted Ginn draft pick that people are calling for his head and blaming this entire mess on him....but most of this IS NOT HIS FAULT.
He did not
draft horribly between 1998 and 2003. It's not his fault that the defense finally collapsed. It's not his fault that most of the roster has been injured. He did not knock out Trent Green. He did not shred Ronnie Brown's knee. He did not give Zach Thomas a concussion
and whiplash.
He's trying to rebuild a putrid team and that takes time. And for those of you that think he should have kept Daunte Culpepper...well, Culpepper has been benched in favor of Josh McCown in Oakland and he looks to be done.
I know that at 0-8 and with a team that is flirting with being one of the worst ever, that the blame will fall on the coach but I can name one guy who for sure has done a worse job than Cameron this season considering the talent he has to work with and that is Norv Turner.
Taking a team that went 14-2 a season ago and that is supposed to be challenging for a Super Bowl and making them seemingly average is a lot worse than taking over a mess, trying to rebuild it and being 0-8 at the midway mark.
I think
Charger fans will
agree with me on that one.